Value-Driven Feedback: Forms for School Teachers

Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

Source: Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

The restorative theme for March is Value-Driven Feedback.

Value-driven feedback gives people information about HOW their choices and actions ALIGN with team or organizational values (such as cooperation, growth-mindset, or grit).


Thus, value-driven feedback lets people know what matters most to us - and in our spaces.

Our values can be injected into both "compliments" and "areas of concern". Yoking our feedback to values is a more effective way to communicate and create change than telling people something is "inappropriate" or "against the rules."

Just in time for parent-teacher conferences (and beyond) below is a sample 2-page Feedback Form with specific behaviors that reflect the values of one particular middle-school classroom.

You can adjust the items on the form to match what matters most in your area - and use the form to create a value-centered conversation with families or kids (see below for Word version of form). An explanation of the form follows.

Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

Source: Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

Source: Elaine Shpungin, Conflict180

Word version of Feedback Form for modification

ABOUT THIS FEEDBACK FORM

The Value-Driven Feedback Form uses a number of findings from the literature on parent-teacher communication and effective feedback, to maximize impact.

(1) The form invites the parents to be PARTNERS in their child's growth - soliciting their wisdom and input.

(2) The form includes an ACTION item for the parent, which has been shown to increase the probability of a parent-child conversation - which can help create change over time.

(3) The form creates an opportunity for BALANCED feedback, as authentic feedback about what WORKS is critical in reminding people to NOT LOSE focus on behaviors that support our values.

(4) The form encourages teachers and parents to be FOCUSED on 1-2 things that have the MOST impact, rather than a long, overwhelming, and disheartening laundry list of everything that needs to change.

How this form can be stronger is to have the items be more OBSERVATIONAL and less subjective. For instance, phrases such as "becoming disruptive" and "acting out" are not useful feedback and would need to be explained in more observational terms to be effective. Ex: "getting up repeatedly and tapping friend on shoulder" "singing out loud when asked to focus and listen". Such behavioral observations would be specific to each child and situation and would need some preparation from the teacher.

Remember that the positive aspects of the Internet outweigh the negatives. The Internet is an excellent educational and recreational resource for children. Encourage your child to make the most of it and explore the internet to its full potential.