Parenting advice: Is it ever OK to tell your child to hit another?

Would you tell your child to hit if you felt like you had done all you can to protect her?

Most parents will teach their children hitting is not acceptable. From those early days of toddlerhood when frustration leads to lashing out at siblings, to the teenage years where rebellion may come as a result of peers and hormone changes, we spend our years reciting things like "We don't hit" and "Do NOT smack!"

But how do we maintain that moral compass when someone else is creating a magnet effect that makes you want to react in a not-so-moral way?

How to raise resilient kids


How to raise resilient kids

"She has asked him to stop"

One mum has posted to Mumsnet asking if she is being unreasonable for considering telling her daughter to hit another child. And before we all jump up and judge, ask yourself what you would do given the same situation.

She said her five-year-old daughter has been having issues with a boy in her class. They have a rug in the classroom with pictures on it and each sign is assigned a picture to sit in the same spot each day.

Talk about the risks associated with meeting online “friends” in person. Adults should understand that the internet can be a positive meeting place for children, where they can get to know other young people and make new friends. However, for safety and to avoid unpleasant experiences, it is important that children do not meet strangers they have met online without being accompanied by an adult you trust. In any case, the child should always have their parents’approval first. In addition, it is also a good idea to have a fail-safe plan in place such as calling them shortly after the meeting begins so that they can bail out if they feel uncomfortable.

"The boy next to her is continually touching her, stroking her hair, face and her arms and legs and she has asked him to stop," the woman wrote.

"I have been in and spoken to them about it and it's still happening almost two months later."

She says the school "don't seem to be doing much" about it. They have spoken to the boy on several occasions but he continues to touch her.

She asks if it would be unreasonable for her to tell the teacher again, but if nothing changes this time, to tell her daughter to hit him.

She says, "I know it's trivial to some but this child is invading her personal space multiple times a day and if this were to happen to an adult I'm sure heads would roll."

Image: iStock.

The young boy was always sat next to the little girl. Image: iStock.

"Never condone violence"

While the responses online were mixed, many quickly pointed out that it was very wrong of the mother to suggest her daughter resort to physical violence.

"What if he hit her back?" one person asked. "That's not the answer. Ask the teacher to separate them, surely they can move spots on the carpet? And have a word with the boy's parents too. But never condone violence."

"Everyone should have kids. They are the greatest joy in the world. But they are also terrorists. You’ll realize this as soon as they are born and they start using sleep deprivation to break you." - Ray Romano

"The teacher really should have separated them by now," added another, adding "I think you have a teacher problem too."

Many advocated for separating the children or demanding the girl be moved, while others pointed out the boy should be relocated, not the girl who has done nothing wrong.

"She has the right to defend herself"

There were also more old-school style responses supporting the need for physical violence.

"That is creepy," wrote one. "You tried the proper channels, it didn't work, she has the right to defend herself."

Another said it's "not ideal, but I would certainly be saying the same thing to my daughter in those circumstances. I never hit back at school and hugely regret it now."

"Tell her to shout"

Many suggested the little girl assert herself loud enough for the boy to stop, or the teacher to hear.

"Tell her to shout, 'get off me' or 'stop touching me' every single time," suggested one person, adding, "He will stop or be stopped."

Another agreed, adding the woman should also "go into the school and tell them that's exactly what you've told her to do."

Apps for kids – do YOUR homework. More than 80,000 apps are labeled as educational, but little research has demonstrated their actual quality. Products pitched as "interactive" should require more than "pushing and swiping." Look to organizations like Common Sense Media for reviews about age-appropriate apps, games and programs to guide you in making the best choices for your children.

"She does need to tell him to stop quite loudly and the teacher needs to keep them apart ... And I would go up the food chain if it's not addressed immediately," said another.

Have you ever been in this situation? Share how you handled it with us in the comments.